Premium research interface

The modern interface for aviation safety intelligence.

Search investigations, review source evidence, monitor watched reports, and trace long-term patterns from one calm, data-first workspace.

63k+
Reports indexed
1940-2026
Coverage
Recent
Last data refresh
Featured Report

Loading…

Loading featured report…

Loading…
Open Report

Safety trends by operating rule

Track fatal and non-fatal accident patterns across Part 91, Part 135, and Part 121 operations.

Loading trend charts…

Browse the aviation graph

Move quickly by aircraft, airport, operator, and time with indexes built for research, not wandering.

Last Data Update

By Decade

By Month

Aircraft Manufacturer

More manufacturers

Airports

More airports

Operators

More operators

About

Aviation safety reports, made easier to study

NTSB Reports is an independent research and search tool for public aviation accident and incident records. It brings NTSB aviation reports, structured fields, docket files, extracted figures, photos, videos, and update history into one searchable interface.

The goal is practical safety education: make it faster to find relevant investigations, compare similar events, review factual records, and understand the evidence behind probable-cause and preliminary reports.

The investigative work and source records belong to the National Transportation Safety Board and the published investigation record. This site is not affiliated with or endorsed by the NTSB.

FAQs

NTSB Report

September 25, 1997 · Universal D-16 · N110N

Howell, MI

Overview

Report Status
Final with probable cause
Event Type
Accident
Date
September 25, 1997
Injury Outcomes
No injuries (2 uninjured)
Location
Howell, MI
Aircraft
Universal D-16
Tail Number
N110N
Injuries
None
Aircraft Damage
Substantial
NTSB Number
CHI97LA301

The instructor pilot had shut down and secured the airplane's left engine as part of a final checkout flight he was giving to a student, prior to her taking her practical test for a multi-engine rating. During the restart attempt, the propeller did not come out of feather, and the engine would not start. The instructor pilot had to manually extend the landing gear, because the hydraulic pump for the gear was on the left engine. They did not get the three green lights, indicating that the airplane's gear was down and locked. The pilot performed a fly-by during which he was informed that the gear appeared to be down. By the time the instructor pilot and student received this information, they were too far down the runway to land, so they executed a go-around. The instructor pilot then took control of the airplane and brought it in for landing. During the touchdown, the landing gear collapsed. Examination of the emergency landing gear extension system revealed that whenever flaps are selected during the hand pumping process, hydraulic pressure to the emergency landing gear system is interrupted, leaving the gear in an intermediate position. Hydraulic pressure is restored once flap extension/retraction is complete.

NTSB Probable Cause

the emergency landing gear extension system being impeded by flap extension. Factors contributing to this accident are the instructor pilot's intentional feathering of the airplane's left propeller, the instructor pilot's lack of familiarity with the airplane, and insufficient information provided in the pilot's operating handbook warning the operator that extending flaps during emergency gear extension will interrupt hydraulic pressure to the system.

Full Narrative

On September 25, 1997, at 1147 eastern daylight time (edt), an Universal Temco D-16, N110N, operated by a certified flight instructor, sustained substantial damage when the airplane's left engine was shut down for training. During the restart attempt, the left propeller would not come out of feather. Emergency landing gear extension was performed. During the subsequent emergency landing, the airplane's nose gear collapsed. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed at the time of the accident. The instructional flight was being conducted under 14 CFR Part 91. No flight plan was on file. The flight instructor and dual student reported no injuries. The flight originated at New Hudson, Michigan, at 1000 edt. In his written statement, the instructor pilot said he had shut down and secured the airplane's left engine as part of a final checkout flight he was giving to a student, prior to her taking her practical test for a multi-engine rating. During the restart attempt, the propeller would not come out of feather, and the engine would not start. The instructor pilot said that they had to manually pump down the landing gear, because the hydraulic pump for the gear was powered by the left engine. The three green lights, indicating that the airplane's landing gear was down and locked, did not illuminate. On their approach into Livingston County Airport, Howell, Michigan, the instructor pilot called the airport manager to visually confirm that the airplane's landing gear were down. The manager told the instructor pilot that the landing gear appeared to be down. By the time the instructor pilot and student received this information, they were too far down the runway to land, so they executed a go-around. The instructor pilot then took control of the airplane and brought it in for landing. During the touchdown, the landing gear collapsed. A Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) inspector examined the wreckage at the accident site. Both wings were bent down outboard of the engines approximately mid-way between the engine nacelles and the wing tip tanks, allowing the tip tanks to rest on the ground. The flaps were found partially extended. Both main landing gear struts were broken aft. The fuselage aft of the wings showed skin wrinkling. The nose wheel was found partially retracted in the wheel well. The right propeller showed chordwise scratches, torsional bending, and tip curling. The left propeller was found in the feathered position. Flight control continuity was confirmed. Examination of the engines, propellers, engine controls, and propeller controls revealed no anomalies. Examination of the airplane's normal landing gear extension system revealed no anomalies. Examination of the emergency landing gear extension system revealed that whenever flaps are selected during the hand pumping process, hydraulic pressure to the emergency landing gear system is interrupted, leaving the gear in an intermediate position. Hydraulic pressure is restored once flap extension/retraction is complete. The landing gear emergency extension procedure in the original pilot operating handbook for the airplane, made no reference cautioning pilots to not extend flaps when using the landing gear emergency extension procedure.

Flight

Event TypeAccident
Event Time11:47 EDT
Nearest AirportLivingston County (1nm SE)
Runway31
Runway Length4300 ft
Runway Width75 ft
Flight Plan FiledNone
Aircraft FireNo
Aircraft ExplosionNo

Aircraft

AircraftUniversal D-16
Tail NumberN110N
Aircraft CategoryAir
DamageSubstantial
Operating RulePart 91
Engines2
Engine TypeReciprocating
Engine DetailsLycoming · O-320-A1A · Reciprocating · 170
Seats4

People & Injuries

Injury SummaryNo injuries (2 uninjured)
Fatal0
Serious0
Minor0
Uninjured2
Total2
Crew 1Age 59 · First Class

Conditions

ConditionsVMC
LightDaylight
Wind260° @ 15 kt
Visibility10 sm
CeilingNone
Temperature / Dew Point68 F / 54
Altimeter29.00 inHg
Observation Time14:54
Weather SourceWFAC

Appendix: Source Data