Premium research interface

The modern interface for aviation safety intelligence.

Search investigations, review source evidence, monitor watched reports, and trace long-term patterns from one calm, data-first workspace.

63k+
Reports indexed
1940-2026
Coverage
Recent
Last data refresh
Featured Report

Loading…

Loading featured report…

Loading…
Open Report

Safety trends by operating rule

Track fatal and non-fatal accident patterns across Part 91, Part 135, and Part 121 operations.

Loading trend charts…

Browse the aviation graph

Move quickly by aircraft, airport, operator, and time with indexes built for research, not wandering.

Last Data Update

By Decade

By Month

Aircraft Manufacturer

More manufacturers

Airports

More airports

Operators

More operators

About

Aviation safety reports, made easier to study

NTSB Reports is an independent research and search tool for public aviation accident and incident records. It brings NTSB aviation reports, structured fields, docket files, extracted figures, photos, videos, and update history into one searchable interface.

The goal is practical safety education: make it faster to find relevant investigations, compare similar events, review factual records, and understand the evidence behind probable-cause and preliminary reports.

The investigative work and source records belong to the National Transportation Safety Board and the published investigation record. This site is not affiliated with or endorsed by the NTSB.

FAQs

NTSB Report

July 22, 2017 · Applegate Panzl S331E · N331ST

Apple Valley, CA

Overview

Report Status
Final with probable cause
Event Type
Accident
Date
July 22, 2017
Injury Outcomes
1 injury (1 fatality)
Location
Apple Valley, CA
Aircraft
Applegate Panzl S331E (2005)
Tail Number
N331ST
Injuries
Fatal
Aircraft Damage
Substantial
NTSB Number
WPR17FA161

The private pilot was practicing her aerobatics routine. During the sixth figure of a nine-figure sequence, the pilot performed a snap roll to the right. Following the snap roll, the pilot performed a left roll as planned; however, rather than entering the next maneuver, the airplane continued to roll left. In-cockpit video indicated that, during the left roll, the right aileron exhibited a trailing-edge-down deflection consistent with a left turn. The pilot then moved her body toward the right side of the cockpit, consistent with a right control stick input. However, the airplane's rate of left roll increased, and the airplane continued to roll to the left as the pilot continued to lean toward the right. At this time, the right aileron indicated a trailing-edge-up deflection consistent with the pilot's right control stick input; the deflection of the left aileron could not be determined. The airplane continued to roll to the left until it impacted the ground. Postaccident examination of the engine revealed no anomalies that would have precluded normal operation. Examination of the airframe revealed a break in the left aileron control assembly and one in the elevator control assembly. Both fracture surfaces of the left aileron control rod end exhibited relatively flat areas emanating from the inner diameter of the outer ring, which transitioned to angular planes adjacent to the outer diameter. One of fracture surfaces exhibited feathery features in the flat area consistent with fatigue cracking; the other fracture surface had smearing damage that obscured most of the finer features. The elevator control fracture exhibited features consistent with shear overstress. The smearing damage indicated that the fatigue crack had been forming for some time. It is likely that the high stresses exerted on the airplane during aerobatic flight resulted in the final fracture of the left aileron control rod end due to fatigue.

NTSB Probable Cause

A fatigue failure of the left aileron control rod end during aerobatic flight, which resulted in the pilot's inability to maintain control of the airplane.

Full Narrative

HISTORY OF FLIGHTOn July 22, 2017, about 1500 Pacific daylight time, an Applegate Panzl S331E airplane, N331ST, impacted terrain while conducting aerobatic maneuvers near Apple Valley, California. The private pilot was fatally injured and the airplane sustained substantial damage. The airplane was registered to the pilot who was operating the airplane under the provisions of Title 14 Code of Federal Regulations Part 91. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed, and no flight plan was filed for the local personal flight, which originated from Apple Valley Airport (APV), Apple Valley, California, about 1445. The pilot was practicing her aerobatics routine and was performing the sixth figure of a nine-figure routine when the accident occurred. A witness, who was familiar with the pilot's routine, reported that, as planned, the airplane entered a 45° descent and executed a right snap roll before entering a left roll. The airplane continued its descent, rolling at a slower rate, until it impacted the ground. The witness stated that, when she entered the maneuver, the pilot had adequate altitude to complete it. An in-cockpit video from a camera mounted over the pilot's right shoulder captured the entirety of the accident flight. During the before takeoff engine run-up, the pilot confirmed flight control continuity; the video showed that the aileron surfaces moved accordingly. The pilot departed and began the aerobatic routine about 3 minutes into the flight. About 4 minutes into the routine, the pilot entered a 45° inverted downline and the airplane performed 1.5 snap rolls to the right. The pilot momentarily stopped the roll at 4,100 ft and started a roll to the left. The right aileron surface was observed trailing edge down, and the left aileron surface could not be seen in the video. The pilot moved her body toward the right of the cockpit, consistent with making a right control stick input; however, the airplane continued to roll left and the roll rate increased; the pilot continued to lean toward the right. About this time, the right aileron could be seen in the video with an upward deflection. The deflection of the left aileron could not be determined. The airplane continued to roll to the left until it impacted the ground. The pilot did not transmit any distress calls before the accident. PERSONNEL INFORMATIONThe pilot's most recent third-class Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) medical certificate was issued November 15, 2016. On the application for that certificate, she reported 982 total hours of flight experience, 39 hours of which were in the previous six months. The pilot had been flying aerobatics since 2006. The pilot purchased the airplane in 2015 and accrued about 189 flight hours in the airplane since that time, 45 hours of which were in the previous 12 months. AIRCRAFT INFORMATIONThe airplane's most recent annual inspection was completed on December 8, 2016. The maintenance log entry for the inspection indicated that the airplane was disassembled and reassembled. A new control stick was installed, and the ailerons and aileron hinges and attach points were inspected and all were recorded as satisfactory at this time. AIRPORT INFORMATIONThe airplane's most recent annual inspection was completed on December 8, 2016. The maintenance log entry for the inspection indicated that the airplane was disassembled and reassembled. A new control stick was installed, and the ailerons and aileron hinges and attach points were inspected and all were recorded as satisfactory at this time. WRECKAGE AND IMPACT INFORMATIONThe airplane impacted sandy desert terrain in an approximate 45° nose down, upright attitude. The engine was mostly embedded in a 2-ft-deep crater; the wood propeller blades were fractured near the propeller hub and fragments were found at the bottom of the crater. The engine cowling, cabin, and both wing skins were heavily fragmented and completely separated from the underlying structure. Impact marks consistent with the leading edges of both wings were visible in the sand. The cabin area was heavily damaged. The skin was still attached to the aft fuselage but exhibited crush damage. The empennage was mostly intact and undamaged. Control continuity was established throughout the airframe with two breaks, one in the left aileron control assembly and one in the elevator control assembly. The fracture surfaces of the left aileron control rod end and the elevator control were examined by the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) Materials laboratory. Both fracture surfaces of the left aileron control rod end exhibited relatively flat areas emanating from the inner diameter of the outer ring, which transitioned to angular planes adjacent to the outer diameter. One of the fracture surfaces exhibited smearing damage on much of its flat area that obscured most of the finer features. The other fracture surface exhibited feathery features in the flat area, consistent with fatigue cracking. The elevator control fracture exhibited features consistent with shear overstress. The engine sustained significant crush damage to the oil sump, exhaust system, and induction system. The magnetos were heavily damaged and could not be tested; the ignition harness was destroyed. The top spark plugs were removed; their coloring varied but was consistent with normal operation when compared to the Champion check-a-plug chart. The fuel nozzles were clear of debris and blockages. Borescope examination of the cylinders revealed no mechanical damage or evidence of detonation or foreign object ingestion. The engine was rotated by hand and continuity was established throughout, thumb compression was obtained on all cylinders and the valves moved appropriately. Examination revealed no anomalies that would have precluded normal operation. MEDICAL AND PATHOLOGICAL INFORMATIONThe San Bernardino County Coroner, San Bernardino, California, performed an autopsy of the pilot. The cause of death was listed as multiple blunt force injuries. The FAA Bioaeronautical Sciences Research Laboratory performed forensic toxicology on specimens from the pilot with negative results for carbon monoxide, and drugs. 85 mg/dL ethanol was detected in blood, which was likely the result of postmortem production.

Flight

Event TypeAccident
Event Time15:00 PDT
Nearest AirportApple Valley (3nm ENE)
Flight Plan FiledNone
Aircraft FireNo
Aircraft ExplosionNo

Aircraft

AircraftApplegate Panzl S331E
Tail NumberN331ST
Aircraft CategoryAir
DamageSubstantial
Operating RulePart 91
Engines1
Engine TypeReciprocating
Engine DetailsLycoming · IO-540 EXP · Reciprocating · 290
Seats1

People & Injuries

Injury Summary1 injury (1 fatality)
Fatal1
Serious0
Minor0
Uninjured0
Total1
Crew 1Age 59 · Third Class · Fatal

Conditions

ConditionsVMC
LightDaylight
Wind150° @ 6 kt
Visibility10 sm
CeilingNone
Temperature / Dew Point10 C / 43 C
Altimeter0
Observation Time21:55
Weather SourceWFAC

Appendix: Source Data